April 3, 2023
On February 15, 2023, an adjudicator ordered an employer to pay what could be the “largest employment compensation” ever awarded in New Brunswick history after it abruptly fired the CEO of a health authority: about $2M, including $200K in aggravated (aka “Wallace”) damages. The hiring and the termination processes are equally important – and equally mine-filled – stages of the employment relationship for employers. The widely publicized decision in Dornan v. New Brunswick (Health) is a real-life case study in how not to hire – or to fire – an employee. Here’s a look at what the employer in Dornan did wrong, how it cost the employer, and three lessons you can learn from the employer’s mistakes.
1. Timing (of the Contract) Can Be Everything
The employer’s first – and biggest – mistake is a common one: it introduced a written employment contract with an important new term, after it already had an employment contract with the employee and after he had already started the job.
What Happened. The employer and the employee, Dr. Dornan, negotiated the terms of Dr. Dornan’s contract verbally and over text messages. They eventually reached agreement on the essential terms. No mention was ever made of a without cause “termination clause” that would limit the compensation the employer would pay Dr. Dornan if it terminated his employment without cause before the employment term ended. A short time after Dr. Dornan had started working, the employer presented him with a written employment contract. The written contract had terms the employer and Dr. Dornan had never discussed – including a without cause termination clause. The employer didn’t encourage Dr. Dornan to seek independent legal advice, nor did he. The employer also failed to draw Dr. Dornan’s attention to the new termination clause. The adjudicator said Dr. Dornan “was not a sophisticated employee”; while he might have understood the effect of the termination clause, he thought he had to sign the contract. The adjudicator also considered Dr. Dornan to be “vulnerable” because he had already quit his job and his prior position had been filled; he felt he had no other option but to sign. So, he signed the written contract. When Dr. Dornan sued the employer for wrongful dismissal, the employer tried to rely on the termination clause to limit the compensation it had to pay Dr. Dornan. It failed. The adjudicator decided the termination clause wasn’t enforceable because the employer and Dr. Dornan had already agreed to the contract terms verbally, and the employer didn’t offer Dr. Dornan any “consideration” (something of new value), an essential requirement for any valid contract, in exchange for the new contractual term. The employer argued its payment of Dr. Dornan’s physicians licensing fees was consideration for the termination clause. The adjudicator rejected this argument because the offer to pay the fees happened after the employer presented Dr. Dornan with the written employment contract and the payment was “in no way directly or indirectly linked to the added termination clause”.
The Lesson. Employers have a contract with every employee whether it’s in writing or not. However, it’s often difficult to determine the scope and terms of a verbal contract, with disputes often resolving on the basis of the employer’s word against the employee’s. A well-drafted written employment contract, including a without cause termination clause is crucial in protecting the employer’s interests, helping to avoid and resolve disputes, and ultimately saving the employer time and money. But timing matters: when the employee signs a written contract is just as important as its terms.
2. Fixed-Term Contracts Can Mean Big Payouts
The employer’s second mistake was not appreciating it could be on the hook for the entire value of the contract if the employment relationship went south.
What Happened. Since the termination clause was unenforceable, the adjudicator had to determine the compensation to which Dr. Dornan was entitled. An employee dismissed without cause from indefinite term employment is entitled to “reasonable notice” of the termination unless there’s an enforceable contractual termination clause. The employee is also under a duty to mitigate their damages: to take all reasonable steps to reduce their lost wages (essentially to try to get another job). If an employee doesn’t fulfill this duty, a court can reduce the amount to which the employee is entitled. However, the contract between the employer and Dr. Dornan was for a fixed five-year term – a finite length of time – not an indefinite term. He was only four months into it when his employer dismissed him. The adjudicator confirmed that when there’s a fixed-term contract without an enforceable termination clause or any other term to the contrary, the employee is entitled to compensation for the entire balance of the term of the contract – and that payment isn’t subject to the employee’s normal duty to mitigate their damages (though the employer didn’t enter any evidence that Dr. Dornan failed to mitigate in any event).
The Lesson. An employer’s liability exposure for the termination of a fixed-term contract before the end of the term can be big – a lot bigger than the reasonable notice for the termination of an indefinite term contract. So, avoid them when you can. This doesn’t mean you should never use a fixed-term contract; there are a limited number of circumstances where it makes sense. But think hard about whether an indefinite term or a fixed-term employment contract is the best tool for the job. And either way, be sure that there’s a written, properly implemented contract that includes a well and carefully crafted without cause termination clause. An enforceable termination clause is technical to draft and challenging to enforce: courts interpret them very strictly, and in employees’ favour. Despite these challenges, an enforceable termination clause gives both the employer and the employee greater certainty about the notice period if there’s a “without cause” termination of either a fixed term or an indefinite term employment contract. And while provinces and territories deal differently with the duty to mitigate damages in the case of a fixed-term employment contract, where the duty to mitigate does apply, the employer must still prove the employee failed to meet that duty. This isn’t always an easy task.
3. Callous Conduct Will Cost You
The employer’s third mistake was the insensitive way it chose to end the employee’s employment – and it was costly.
What Happened. The employer asked Dr. Dornan to attend a news conference scheduled for the following day. While he was on his way to the conference, the Premier called and told him his immediate superior had been replaced. The new superior joined the call and told Dr. Dornan “you are no longer employed.” At the news conference, the Premier made comments the adjudicator found could reasonably lead the public to believe he had concluded Dr. Dornan was responsible for an unfortunate hospital emergency room death. The adjudicator was also critical that the employer didn’t meet with Dr. Dornan in private to discuss the termination decision. The adjudicator decided the employer dismissed Dr. Dornan in a “public, disingenuous, callous manner” that diminished his “otherwise stellar reputation”. (The adjudicator also criticized the employer’s failure to provide Dr. Dornan with the “opportunity to address the concerns of the employer”, even though the termination was without cause so there was no requirement for the employer to do so.) The arbitrator awarded Dr. Dornan an additional $200,000 in aggravated damages because of the way the employer carried out the termination (so-called “Wallace” damages).
The Lesson. The end of an employment relationship is often a highly emotional situation for both the employer and the employee. But courts have been crystal clear: employees are particularly vulnerable at the time of termination, and employers have a legal duty not to treat employees unfairly, dishonestly or insensitively in the way they terminate their employment. No matter the reason for or the circumstances of the employment termination, be respectful and professional throughout – or the cost could be high.
Please contact your McInnes Cooper lawyer or any member of our Labour & Employment Law Team @ McInnes Cooper to discuss how we can help you avoid making the mistakes the employer made in Dornan v. New Brunswick (Health).
McInnes Cooper has prepared this document for information only; it is not intended to be legal advice. You should consult McInnes Cooper about your unique circumstances before acting on this information. McInnes Cooper excludes all liability for anything contained in this document and any use you make of it.
© McInnes Cooper, 2023. All rights reserved. McInnes Cooper owns the copyright in this document. You may reproduce and distribute this document in its entirety as long as you do not alter the form or the content and you give McInnes Cooper credit for it. You must obtain McInnes Cooper’s consent for any other form of reproduction or distribution. Email us at [email protected] to request our consent.
Sep 20, 2023
You’ve experienced a workplace accident that’s resulted in serious injury to, or worse the death of, an employee. Do you need legal counsel…
Jun 23, 2023
Effective June 23, 2023, Section 45(1.1) of the Competition Act makes it a criminal offence for all unaffiliated employers to enter into…
Jun 22, 2023
Employers understand the risk that departing employees will take sensitive information, compete for customers and solicit other employees.…
May 18, 2023
Employees used to gather around the water cooler to share views on controversial issues, discuss co-workers and complain about their employer.…
May 1, 2023
While the December 2021 Bill C-223, An Act to Develop a National Framework for a Guaranteed Livable Basic Income seems to have died in both…
Apr 27, 2023
The benefits to employees, and often to employers, of remote work has made it a staple of today’s workplace. But the move to remote work…
Mar 29, 2023
Immigration continues to play a key role in addressing Canada’s labour and skills shortage. Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada…
Mar 27, 2023
On March 21, 2023, the Nova Scotia Minister of Health and Wellness introduced Bill 256, Patient Access to Care Act. If passed, Bill 256 will…
Mar 23, 2023
On February 15, 2023, a New Brunswick adjudicator awarded Dr. John Dornan, the suddenly dismissed CEO of N.B. Health Authority, what might be…
Feb 27, 2023
2022 left important lasting implications for employers. With 2023 here, it’s time to look ahead to key issues that will affect employers in…
Feb 23, 2023
Many Canadian employers continue to be challenged not only with hiring the right number of people, but with finding candidates with the right…
Jan 16, 2023
2022 is in the rearview mirror, but the past year left lasting implications for employers. Here’s a retrospective on five of the key 2022…
Dec 1, 2022
The COVID-19 pandemic drove remote work to unprecedented heights. Employee calls for greater flexibility, and cost savings for employers, have…
Sep 15, 2022
When Prime Minister Trudeau announced that September 19, 2022 would be a National Day of Mourning for Queen Elizabeth II, the Atlantic provinces…
Jun 23, 2022
The current labour crunch is only strengthening the business case for building a workplace that’s welcoming to diverse employee pools –…
Jun 8, 2022
We updated this publication on July 28, 2023. Effective June 1, 2022, Bill 119 amended the P.E.I. Employment Standards Act to add new pay…
May 27, 2022
The COVID-19 pandemic is (arguably) gone but the pre-pandemic labour crunch - for both white and blue collar workers - is back. And there’s no…
Apr 28, 2022
The COVID-19 pandemic changed many aspects of the workplace for good – but pre-pandemic labour shortages isn’t one of them. While the…
Apr 1, 2022
While the Canada emergency response benefit (CERB) has ended, the focus on the concept of a universal or guaranteed basic income the COVID-19…
Mar 24, 2022
COVID-19 public health restrictions are coming to an end, even though the COVID-19 virus is not. Employers face reconstructing their workplace…
Mar 16, 2022
In February 2022, thousands of people led by a convoy of trucks (many displaying company logos) from across Canada congregated in Ottawa and…
Feb 24, 2022
As the Omicron wave wanes, and COVID-19 moves from pandemic to endemic, provincial governments have quickly pivoted to loosening – some even…
Feb 8, 2022
We updated this publication on December 15, 2022. On May 17, 2022, the P.E.I. Non-disclosure Agreements Act took effect, significantly…
Jan 27, 2022
Since COVID-19 vaccinations rolled out, employers have grappled with workplace COVID-19 vaccination policies, with little guidance from courts…
Dec 14, 2021
This publication has been updated as at January 26, 2022. Since COVID-19 vaccinations rolled out, employers have been grappling with how to…
Nov 25, 2021
As COVID-19 continues, many workplaces have morphed from remote work arrangements into hybrid arrangements for many employees. By necessity,…
Oct 28, 2021
COVID-19 forced many employers to make temporary, and even permanent, changes to the terms of employees’ employment, from scheduling and…
Oct 27, 2021
On October 22, 2021, the Supreme Court of Canada, in Northern Regional Health Authority v. Horrocks, clarified that labour arbitrators have…
Sep 21, 2021
We updated this publication on December 14, 2022. COVID-19 has been changing Canadian workplaces for 18 months. For some employees, the…
Jul 21, 2021
Many now agree: it’s imperative that workplaces be both diverse and inclusive. Perhaps the most often-quoted (and definitely most succinct)…
Jun 15, 2021
As of January 1, 2021, federally regulated employers (such as banks, telephone and cable systems, most federal Crown corporations,…
Jun 10, 2021
This publication has been updated as at August 27, 2021. With the COVID-19 vaccine widely available, and the COVID pandemic continuing,…
Mar 31, 2021
Close to five million Canadians who didn’t usually work from home, did so in 2020 because of the COVID-19 pandemic. Even as public health…
Mar 15, 2021
The COVID-19 Pandemic has focused more attention on the concept of a universal or guaranteed basic income that at any other time in modern…
Feb 16, 2021
This publication has been updated as at September 17, 2021. Employers across the country – including the federal government, some…
Jan 21, 2021
Well-drafted, properly implemented written employment contracts are a key tool to avoiding or resolving disputes during and at the end of…
Jan 20, 2021
Termination clauses, particularly “without cause” ones, are among the most important clauses to include in any employment agreement. But the…
Nov 3, 2020
This publication has been updated as at July 9, 2021. For some time, every Prince Edward Island employer has been required to comply with…
Oct 19, 2020
On October 9, 2020, the Supreme Court of Canada delivered its decision in Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition Canada Ltd. on whether a former employee…
Aug 12, 2020
This publication has been updated as of May 5, 2021. The ongoing COVID-19 pandemic has led many employees to continue working from home, by…
Jul 6, 2020
On June 26, 2020, the Supreme Court of Canada released Uber Technologies Inc. v. Heller, a much-awaited decision regarding the enforceability of…
May 14, 2020
This publication has been updated as of April 23, 2021. Employers that hire and employ temporary foreign workers must comply with many and…
Apr 30, 2020
While the world is still reeling from ongoing COVID-19 concerns, many provinces have announced plans to relax public health restrictions put in…
Apr 15, 2020
The COVID-19 pandemic is disrupting more than Canada’s domestic workforce. It’s also disrupting Canadian employers’ access to temporary…
Mar 27, 2020
The COVID-19 novel coronavirus has evolved rapidly, and so have the workplace issues employers are facing – and the questions employers were…
Mar 12, 2020
The havoc that COVID-19 (a.k.a. “novel coronavirus” or SARS-CoV-2) is wreaking around the globe – and around workplaces – is about to…
Oct 10, 2019
“Do the unexpected. Take 20 minutes out of your day, do what young people all over the world are dying to do: vote.” Rick Mercer (hailing…
Sep 6, 2019
This publication has been updated as at July 9, 2021. Violence and harassment is an unfortunate reality of society – and of the workplace.…
Jun 5, 2019
Like it or not, Canadians live life online. More people - and more employees - are sharing more information, images and opinions with more…
Apr 8, 2019
Growing a business takes people. In early days, many startups have just one “employee”: the founder. At some point, the founder might retain…
Feb 27, 2019
This publication has been updated as at July 9, 2021. As of April 1, 2019, employers of New Brunswick employees must comply with new…
Feb 22, 2019
As of April 1, 2019, employers of New Brunswick employees must comply with new occupational health and safety law requirements specific to…
Dec 19, 2018
On December 13, 2018, the Supreme Court of Canada confirmed that a third party can’t waive a person’s right to privacy or their rights under…
Dec 18, 2018
On December 18, 2018, the maximum sentence possible for impaired driving (among other things) will increase as the result of amendments to…
Dec 13, 2018
This publication has been updated as of October 15, 2020. Canada became only the second country in the world to legalize cannabis (or…
Sep 28, 2018
Immigration is one of the key solutions to looming (and current) worker shortages in Canada. But an employer that hires a foreign worker must…
Sep 4, 2018
Immigration is one of the key solutions to the looming (or in some cases, current) worker shortage in Canada. In her article, The Top 5…
Jul 16, 2018
Every parent knows that a lot can happen in 18 months. Many employers agree. The federal government’s extension of employment insurance…
Jun 27, 2018
The legalization of recreational cannabis in Canada is imminent. Employers are feeling the heat to prepare – even as they continue efforts to…
Jun 8, 2018
This publication has been updated as of September 28, 2020. In the last few years, many employers have been focused on preparing for and…
May 11, 2018
This article has been updated as of January 19, 2022. It can be challenging for employers to fulfill their legal duty to accommodate an…
Apr 26, 2018
The N.S. Court of Appeal has reached two decisions ending one employee’s quest for coverage of the costs of his medical marijuana – at least…
Apr 2, 2018
Workplace sexual harassment isn’t a new issue, nor is it limited to any one industry or country – but it's one that far more women than men…
Apr 2, 2018
Equity compensation plans are a valuable and versatile tool for many corporations, from early-stage startups to established blue-chips.…
Mar 29, 2018
We updated this publication on March 11, 2020. The #metoo and #timesup movements drove workplace sexual harassment to the front and center of…
Feb 2, 2018
Many employers use written workplace policies as a day-to-day workplace management tool; common examples include attendance management policies,…
Jan 25, 2018
Insurers have generally been leery of coverage for medical cannabis in both the health benefit claims and in cost of care claims in the personal…
Dec 18, 2017
The answer to the question, “What’s employers’ rationale for implementing workplace drug and alcohol testing?” is pretty…
Dec 8, 2017
This article has been updated as of December 2, 2021. For many people, the holiday season now upon us is a fun-filled time of the year. But…
Oct 31, 2017
Intellectual Property (IP) can be a valuable asset – even the most valuable asset – of a business. So it’s worth making sure the business…
Sep 22, 2017
Canada’s most important trading relationship is – in all likelihood – about to change: the current U.S. administration has put the future…
Sep 21, 2017
This publication has been updated as at January 13, 2022. An increasing number of employees are struggling to meet the challenge of the…
Aug 11, 2017
After years of low interest rates, and correspondingly high solvency liabilities, there’s growing recognition that the solvency funding model…
Jul 28, 2017
This publication has been updated as of October 14, 2020. On June 19, 2017, Bill C-16, An Act to amend the Canadian Human Rights Act and the…
Jul 28, 2017
We udpated this publication on June 10, 2022. The rapid rise in ESG (Environment, Social and Governance) principles has increased focus on…
Jul 13, 2017
More employees are seeking flexible work arrangements as a new way of working to better juggle their family and personal responsibilities. In…
May 19, 2017
Investigations are a vital - but difficult - part of workplace management. The value of a proper investigation can’t be overstated: it plays a…
May 16, 2017
Recreational cannabis isn’t legal yet: Canada’s federal government has proposed legislation to legalize and regulate access to recreational…
Apr 20, 2017
On April 13, 2017, Canada’s federal government introduced legislation that, if passed into law, will legalize recreational cannabis in Canada.…
Apr 17, 2017
Recreational cannabis isn’t legal yet - but much of the associated stigma is already gone, usage is up and employers are feeling the workplace…
Feb 22, 2017
On January 1, 2022, the Atlantic Immigration Pilot Program became the permanent Atlantic Immigration Program (AIP). Learn more at From Pilot to…
Jan 31, 2017
We updated this publication on April 5, 2023. The hiring process and the termination process are equally important stages of the employment…
Dec 13, 2016
Employers’ legal duty to accommodate employees seems to most frequently come up in the context of employees with disabilities. But that duty…
Nov 22, 2016
Canada’s most important trading relationship might undergo some change with the results of the 2016 U.S. election. Facilitating cross-border…
Nov 15, 2016
The employment contract is an exchange of labour for wages and other benefits, so employers are entitled to expect regular ongoing attendance…
Oct 19, 2016
Business owners wear many hats – including employer. Your employees may be your business’s greatest asset, but they could also be your…
Sep 29, 2016
Whether someone is an employee or an independent contractor has long caused employers a degree of angst. And the recent emergence of a new…
Jul 15, 2016
On July 14, 2016, the Supreme Court of Canada decided that the “Unjust Dismissal” sections of the Canada Labour Code ensure that…
Jun 30, 2016
As of June 25, 2016, provincially regulated workers and employers in Nova Scotia, Quebec, BC and Saskatchewan can participate in Pooled…
Jun 29, 2016
Employers are entitled to mandate dress codes in the workplace, and even to discipline employees who refuse to comply. But a workplace dress…
May 2, 2016
We updated this publication on May 8, 2023. “Due diligence” is a legal defence to many charges under occupational health and safety (OHS)…
Mar 9, 2016
On January 11, 2016, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice sentenced a front-line supervisor to imprisonment for 3½ years for four counts of…
Feb 23, 2016
Employee tardiness is a significant problem for employers - and bad weather is one of the top three reasons that employees give for it according…
Feb 1, 2016
We updated this publication on April 13, 2023. A well drafted and properly implemented written employment contract can be instrumental to…
Dec 7, 2015
Violence has become an unfortunate reality in current society, and the workplace is not immune. With more people spending more time at work,…
Aug 13, 2015
The employment contract, at its core, is an exchange of work for compensation. So at a very basic level, employers are entitled to expect…
Jun 25, 2015
We updated this publication on May 9, 2023. Most people know a company itself has occupational health and safety (OHS) obligations and risks…
Mar 31, 2015
This publication has been updated as at June 24, 2021. Women make up close to half of the employed workforce: in 2019, Canadian women 15…
Feb 13, 2015
This publication has been updated as at January 26, 2022. With people spending so many of their waking hours at or connected to work these…
Feb 2, 2015
On January 30, 2015 the Supreme Court of Canada decided that the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedom’s protection for freedom of…
Jan 30, 2015
In December 2014, the NL Supreme Court ordered an employer to pay its former employee $30,000 in moral damages to compensate him for the mental…
Dec 11, 2014
On December 11, 2014 the Supreme Court of Canada continued its trend to recognize privacy rights – and develop the law to protect them –…
Dec 5, 2014
This article has been updated as of December 11, 2020. Employers host numerous events throughout the year – summer and holiday office…
Nov 27, 2014
Recently, the NS Court of Appeal confirmed that a union can be certified as the bargaining agent of employees based merely on their dependence…
Sep 30, 2014
Effective September 1, 2014 the NB government implemented five important changes to the NB Employment Standards Act – the minimum standards…
Jul 9, 2014
On June 20, 2014 the Federal Government announced a major overhaul of Canada’s Temporary Foreign Worker Program. With stringent enforcement…
Apr 3, 2014
On March 28, 2014 the Federal Government tabled Bill C-31 to implement the 2014 Federal Budget – including broad authority to impose cash…
Jan 21, 2014
On December 31, 2013, amendments to the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations and new Ministerial Instructions changing the Federal…
Nov 8, 2013
On November 7, 2013, the SCC decided police require specific authorization in a search warrant to search the data in a computer because of the…
Jul 2, 2013
On June 14, 2013, the Supreme Court of Canada’s decision in Communications, Energy and Paperworkers Union of Canada, Local 30 v. Irving Pulp…
Apr 30, 2013
Note: Effective December 31, 2013, the Federal Government made additional changes to the Federal Temporary Foreign Worker Program. Click here to…
Jan 8, 2013
On November 19, 2012, the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) unanimously ruled a B.C. public school system’s failure to provide adequate and…
Nov 28, 2012
On October 19, 2012 the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) decided that a teacher criminally charged with possession of child pornography and…
Oct 22, 2012
Mr. Cole was a high school teacher with an employer owned and issued laptop computer. He also used it for incidental personal purposes, which…
Jul 10, 2012
On March 16, 2012, the Supreme Court of Canada (“SCC”) confirmed the decision of the N.S. Court of Appeal, reinstating the N.S. Human Rights…
Jun 14, 2012
As any Canadian knows, July 1st – Canada Day – is the first long weekend of the summer; or is it? This year, July 1st falls on a Sunday. …
Mar 1, 2012
Social media represents a profound cultural shift and employers must adapt if they want to avoid unnecessarily – and potentially costly –…
Jan 5, 2012
Effective January 1, 2012, NS’s Human Rights Commission will receive, investigate and handle complaints under NS’s Human Rights Act under a…
Dec 19, 2011
In a decision with application to Atlantic Canada, the Ontario Court of Appeal found that an employer’s multiple extensions of a terminated…
Aug 6, 2011
Note: On June 14, 2013 the Supreme Court of Canada issued its decision in Communications, Energy and Paperworkers Union of Canada, Local 30 v.…
May 6, 2011
In March 2011, the Ontario Court of Appeal found that an employee had a limited expectation of privacy in the contents of a work computer. The…
Mar 6, 2011
In the midst of a sea of change, the Federal Government has enacted Regulatory changes significantly impacting employers who hire foreign…
Subscribe to McInnes Cooper to stay current with our leading insights on legal updates, trends, news, events, and services.